![](media/image-e8f4b60d25498e573d688c63a0461437dc002ec0.png){width="2.6466666666666665in"
height="0.6666666666666666in"}

**Lets draft up a detailed presentation refinement for Phase Mirror
based on this analysis.**

Here is a detailed, presentation-ready refinement you can drop into a
Phase Mirror pitch or deck. It keeps the central tension
front-and-center and differentiates clearly from Speculum-style runtime
enforcers.

**1. Opening Frame: The Central Tension**

**Slide: The Permanent Contradiction in Agentic AI**

-   Agentic AI wants to **act**; enterprises must **govern** those
    actions.[^[\[1\]]{.underline}^](#fn1)

-   Autonomy vs. governance is not a bug you "fix" once; it is a
    **permanent tension** you must name, monitor, and rebind as systems
    evolve.[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)

-   Most tools jump straight to enforcement: more policies, more gates,
    more dashboards.

-   Phase Mirror starts earlier in the lifecycle: it **finds and names
    dissonance** in your AI stack before it becomes
    liability.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

Speaker note: "We don't sell you a 'safety switch.' We sell you a
systematic way to see where your AI, your policies, and your
infrastructure disagree---before regulators or incidents
do."[^[\[1\]]{.underline}^](#fn1)

**2. What Phase Mirror Is (and Is Not)**

**Slide: Phase Mirror in One Sentence**

> Phase Mirror is a *diagnostic governance oracle* for agentic AI: a
> callable, auditable protocol that turns vague AI risk into
> deterministic dissonance reports wired into your CI/CD and governance
> artifacts.[^[\[4\]]{.underline}^](#fn4)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

**Slide: Where We Sit in the Stack**

-   **Not**: A runtime firewall that intercepts agent actions at
    decision-time.

-   **Is**: A build-time and change-time oracle that:

    -   Scans repos, workflows, policies, and
        configs.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

    -   Detects **tensions** between what your AI is allowed to do and
        what your systems actually permit.[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)

    -   Outputs deterministic, evidence-rich reports (files, lines,
        configs) that plug into pull requests, merge queues, and drift
        detection.[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

Visual framing (textual): Dev & policy loop on the left (Phase Mirror),
runtime on the right (optional enforcers). Phase Mirror feeds
"governance truth" into both.

**3. Core Ideas: Mirror, Dissonance, Phase**

**Slide: The Phase Mirror Methodology**

-   **Mirror** --- Reflect the current state of claims, configs, and
    code back to you without judgment.[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)

    -   Example: "Your board policy says oracle-check is mandatory; your
        actual branch protections do not enforce
        it."[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

-   **Dissonance** --- Identify structural contradictions and missing
    bindings.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)

    -   Example: "Your agent is configured to optimize for model
        accuracy, while your policy mandates compliance-first for
        regulated flows."[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

-   **Phase** --- Propose small, testable shifts---new specs, SLAs,
    contracts, and pipeline rules---with owners, metrics, and
    horizons.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)

Speaker note: "The method forces you to replace vibes with artifacts:
specs, ADRs, SLAs, kill-switch protocols, and policy
bindings."[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

**4. Product: The Oracle and Its Surfaces**

**Slide: The Phase Mirror Oracle**

-   **L0 Invariants** (always-on, non-negotiable):

    -   Schema integrity, permission bits, drift thresholds, nonce
        freshness, contraction witness
        checks.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

    -   Target: \~100 ns p99; cheap enough that *not* running them is
        the risk.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

-   **Rule System (L1)**:

    -   MD-001..005: branch protection alignment, autonomy vs.
        compliance policy encoding, probabilistic outputs, liability
        framework, drift.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

-   **False Positive Store + Circuit Breaker**:

    -   FP tracking with DynamoDB, windowed FPR, k-anonymity calibration
        across
        orgs.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

    -   Circuit breaker with degraded-mode behavior when thresholds are
        hit.[^[\[8\]]{.underline}^](#fn8)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

**Slide: How Teams Use It Day-to-Day**

-   Developers:

    -   phase-mirror analyze wired into PR checks, merge queues, and
        GitHub Code Scanning via SARIF.[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

    -   CLI outputs: pass / warn / block decisions plus evidence and
        remediation hints.[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

-   Governance & Compliance:

    -   Consume JSON dissonance reports and dashboards that show where
        policy and reality
        diverge.[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

-   SRE / Platform:

    -   Drift detection on schedules, FP spikes, and circuit breaker
        status integrated into their observability
        stack.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

**5. Unique Differentiators (vs. Runtime Enforcers)**

**Slide: Four Things Only Phase Mirror Does Together**

1.  **Names the Tension, Doesn't Hide It**

    -   The UI's primary job is to display dissonance, not green-light
        everything.[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

    -   Every tension becomes a lever with owner, metric, horizon---not
        just a red X in a dashboard.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

2.  **Open-Core, Governance-Grade**

    -   Core Oracle, L0 invariants, and base rules are open-source under
        a source-available license with a managed-service
        restriction.[^[\[4\]]{.underline}^](#fn4)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

    -   Self-hosted community tier is genuinely useful (full CLI, rules,
        FP marking, L0 validation) with no artificial seat
        caps.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

3.  **FP Calibration as Network-Effect Moat**

    -   Cross-customer, anonymized FP calibration makes rules smarter
        over
        time.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

    -   Opt-in consent model, revocable, with clear data ownership and
        post-churn behavior spelled out.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)

4.  **Governance Artifacts as First-Class Outputs**

    -   Engagements always end in specs, SLAs, kill-switch protocols,
        and board-ready packets, not just
        dashboards.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

    -   Compliance packs encode NIST AI RMF, ISO 42001, EU AI Act,
        sector-specific rules into reusable
        modules.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

**6. Commercial Design: The Four Pillars**

**Slide: Business Architecture**

-   **Open-Core SaaS Platform**

    -   Community: free, self-hosted, core rules and
        CLI.[^[\[4\]]{.underline}^](#fn4)[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

    -   Team/Business/Enterprise tiers: more rules, SLAs, dashboards,
        and dedicated instances.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

-   **Enterprise Seats & Compliance Packs**

    -   Industry packs for Financial Services, Healthcare, EU AI Act
        readiness, Agentic AI Governance,
        etc.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

-   **Certification**

    -   Practitioner tracks (PMA, CPMP, CPMA) and "Phase Mirror
        Certified" implementations and
        partners.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

-   **Professional Services**

    -   AI Governance Diagnostic, Compliance-Accuracy Tradeoff
        Workshops, advisory retainers, implementation
        services.[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

Speaker note: "The license ensures only Proof Labs can run 'Phase Mirror
as a Service', but anyone can self-host, extend, and embed it deeply in
their stack."[^[\[4\]]{.underline}^](#fn4)

**7. Refined Narrative for the Deck**

You can reframe the talk-track around three questions:

1.  **Where do you want to govern your AI---only at runtime, or also at
    design and change time?**

    -   Phase Mirror sits upstream, in CI/CD and governance
        processes.[^[\[2\]]{.underline}^](#fn2)[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

2.  **Do you want a black-box enforcer, or a mirror that shows you *why
    governance is breaking?***

    -   Phase Mirror produces human-readable, evidence-backed dissonance
        reports tied to
        artifacts.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

3.  **Are you building a tool, or adopting an operating system for AI
    governance?**

    -   Methodology + Oracle + UI + services + certification ecosystem;
        not just a single product
        SKU.[^[\[4\]]{.underline}^](#fn4)[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

**8. Levers, Metrics, Horizons (for the Presentation Itself)**

To keep operating in Phase Mirror style, treat the presentation as an
object under governance:

-   **Lever 1 -- Clarify Build-time Positioning**

    -   Owner: You.

    -   Metric: First 3 slides explicitly say "build-time diagnostic
        oracle, not runtime firewall."

    -   Horizon: First draft of deck updated within 7
        days.[^[\[5\]]{.underline}^](#fn5)

-   **Lever 2 -- Open-Core Proof of Seriousness**

    -   Owner: Engineering + GTM.

    -   Metric: Community tier: install → first useful dissonance report
        \< 5 minutes, demo-able
        live.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)[^[\[6\]]{.underline}^](#fn6)

    -   Horizon: Ready for live demo in next board / investor
        presentation.

-   **Lever 3 -- FP Calibration Story**

    -   Owner: Product.

    -   Metric: One dedicated slide clearly explaining how FP
        calibration works, consent model, and why this is the durable
        moat.

    -   Horizon: Slide added before next enterprise prospect
        meeting.[^[\[7\]]{.underline}^](#fn7)[^[\[3\]]{.underline}^](#fn3)

Precision question to close: *Is this presentation optimizing for
winning the "governance budget" against incumbent GRC tools, or for
earning a new "agentic AI reliability" line item alongside runtime
enforcers?* The answer should drive which examples and comparisons you
front-load.

⁂

1.  Agentic Domain-Specific Reasoning.pdf

2.  A-Clear-Guide-to-Phase-Mirror-s-Services.pdf

3.  Phase-Mirror\_-Comprehensive-Services-Catalog.docx.pdf

4.  Phase-Mirror\_-Consultation-SaaS.pdf

5.  [[lets-analyze-the-phase-mirror-KxbpLF05TkmkJ5C3R17zHw.md]{.underline}](http://lets-analyze-the-phase-mirror-KxbpLF05TkmkJ5C3R17zHw.md)

6.  [[if-phase-mirror-had-a-ui-ux-wh-42aRj49CSACSlpWdD.YCfA.md]{.underline}](http://if-phase-mirror-had-a-ui-ux-wh-42aRj49CSACSlpWdD.YCfA.md)

7.  Phase-mirror-dissonance\_\_\_Open-core-must-be-useful.pdf

8.  [[lets-analyze-the-phase-mirror-zcQHcEC1RSa.hpTZS8CnrQ.md]{.underline}](http://lets-analyze-the-phase-mirror-zcQHcEC1RSa.hpTZS8CnrQ.md)

9.  [[lets-start-by-expanding-phase-uqsmNdbnR92HAuxFBWGvjA.md]{.underline}](http://lets-start-by-expanding-phase-uqsmNdbnR92HAuxFBWGvjA.md)
